Elektrine lite

← Feed

@dejaeghere@mastodon.social

2026-03-04 09:31 UTC

@HarryMutt@social.vivaldi.net @katemorley@hachyderm.io Australia. But there is a host of ways and some are probably too complex...Single (non-) transferable, mixed member proportional,...Borda count...even the odd ones that disappeared where you could give fractions of votes to different parties (belgian local elections until the mid seventies did this, a system called "panacher")...in the end all better than FPTP... Just have a national Citizens Assembly, present all, have a random group debate and choose

Replies (1)

  • @dejaeghere@mastodon.social @katemorley@hachyderm.io Ah, ok. A "panacher" system is the one used for communal elections in some federal states here in Germany. You can give more weight to single candidates or strike out others, or just mark a party list which then gets all your votes distributed down their candidates. Every system has its ups and downs. In a FPTP system, forming a stable government is easier. In a proportional system, there can be many parties, and forming a coalition can be slow and difficult. But it represents the will of the people much better imho. This reminds me of what I heard in a BBC podcast series about German history from 2014, I think. Neil MacGregor, former head of the British Museum, said something very interesting about how differently the UK and Germany dealt with the multinational politics in the EU. According to him, Britain always had problems with that because coalition-building and compromises were never seen positively in a country with centralized power structure. Germany, on the other hand, throughout its history, except for the 12-year-millenium of the nazis, has always been structured federally, with often long and tiresome negotiations to find compromises. The same is probably true for regular politics. That one time Britain had a coalition government seems not to be remembered positively. ;-)

    Open ##2657400