Elektrine lite

← Feed

@anlomedad@fedifreu.de

2026-10-08 11:37 UTC

@GhostOnTheHalfShell@masto.ai @FriedhelmFeldmann@mastodon.social @rahmstorf@fediscience.org That's the mosaic and European-centred narrative alright. But. Climate changed over loooong periods and in the subtropics and tropics, the changes were subtle*. Subtle enough to enable semi-settled tribes, kind of like multi-seasonal migratory birds, who regularly returned to their favourite caves, for example near important flint depositories or other important resources. Modern humans lived in a cave in Morocco for over 300ky. The cave is elevated and overlooks a plain with lake and river that was probably teeming with wildlife. A prehistoric drive-in Mcdonald's. They didn't have to settle and rely on stationary agriculture because foraging, hunting, fishing was enough to sustain their lifestyle. And I believe, but without any scientific source to prove it, that they DID encourage particular plants to grow along their migratory paths. To ensure that their favourite nut or their favourite cereal awaited them when they returned. *subtle climate change in subtropics and tropics – unless AMOC hickupped. Which ofc drives the rainbelt South and spells drought in places otherwise favoured by humans. But that too occurred on manageable timelines. Manageable in particular for the semi-settled cultures. The fact that humans did settle permanently in Mesopotamia from 12ky ago onwards, a region which was already home to modern humans for 100ky before that, I believe, that wasn't enabled by a stable climate. I think, it was a cultural choice. You know, something like a religion that required regular sacrifices, and at special locations. Which made the previous semi-settled lifestyle impractical. Such a stationary religion was surely useful for the psychopaths in tribes who thrive on powergrab, manipulation, and other yuck personality traits. So I reckon, psychopaths invented stationary religions and everything else developed in its wake, agricultural practices too.

Replies (3)

  • @anlomedad@fedifreu.de 2026-10-08 12:00

    @GhostOnTheHalfShell@masto.ai @FriedhelmFeldmann@mastodon.social @rahmstorf@fediscience.org The drive-in McDonald's in Morocco: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jebel_Irhoud#Site

    Open ##5231196

  • @anlomedad@fedifreu.de @FriedhelmFeldmann@mastodon.social @rahmstorf@fediscience.org I am reasonably familiar with the literature that debates the topic of why settled agriculture emerged over a period of 3000 years at the boundary of 12k years ago. What I am repeating is the gist of that thinking The argument that stationary settlement is good for psychopaths doesn’t hold up as well. cultural anthropologists worked on the topic of social structure for 30 years settling on a framework defining the relevant factors in the 90s.

    Open ##5231197

  • @anlomedad@fedifreu.de @FriedhelmFeldmann@mastodon.social @rahmstorf@fediscience.org Well, this really isn’t the place to litigate that consensus, But archaeological findings, all point to permanent settlements, emerging globally in the same timeframe. You can’t argue that it was regional to Europe or even the Middle East

    Open ##5231200